
One system can be used to completely meet all water table management requirements. The drainage and irrigation components of a subirrigation system are one and the same. Installing a subirrigation system costs less than installing subsurface drainage and surface irrigation together. For certain soils, subirrigation is very efficient. Deep seepage is negligible, and no runoff of irrigation water occurs. The water is always applied where the crops require it. Most importantly, crops respond well to subirrigation when other production management factors are not limiting. In ten years of study, bean yields have been consistently over 75 bushels per acre under subirrigation and a high yield management system.
REQUIREMENTS FOR SUBIRRIGATIONSoil. Subirrigation is usually effective in soils that have a soil layer of low permeability located below the subsurface drains. This layer helps reduce deep seepage losses. The permeability of the restrictive layer should be less than one-tenth that of the crop root zone.
Both vertical and horizontal hydraulic conductivities should be measured in the field before designing the system. High horizontal hydraulic conductivity creates the potential for lateral seepage. This allows for a wider drain spacing. However, losses from the edge of the field may be excessive under these conditions, especially if the adjoining field is drained.
Topography. Subirrigation is best suited for flat or gently sloping lands (less than 1% slope) because uniform depth to the water table is much easier to maintain. A field with considerable surface undulation could result in excessive variation of depth to the water table. For this case, water table management may require multiple control structures.
Management. Management is very important and time requirements may be high. Until the farmer is well acquainted with the system, monitoring the water table both over and between the drains may be necessary. Automated water level controllers reduce time inputs but are much more costly. Raising the water table four feet in a sandy loam soil with drains 60 feet apart could take 3 to 5 days. Times would be longer for clay soils.
Drainage Drainage system improvements may be necessary to adequately distribute the irrigation water. Drain spacing may need to be closer than required for drainage alone for certain soils. Surface improvements, such as land grading or field ditches, may be useful.
Ability to drain rapidly when rainfall occurs during subirrigation periods is critical.
Water Supply. Water is needed most during the driest parts of the growing season. Streams are often unreliable, because flow rates decrease when water demand is highest. Wells, ponds, and reservoirs are used frequently for irrigation water supply. Net irrigation water requirements in the Midwest depend on crop, location, and weather. Irrigation to meet evapotranspiration demand may typically require 5 gallons per acre per minute.
Materials. Materials include the subsurface drainage system with its control structures, a properly sized pump, and perhaps monitoring wells (piezometers) at several locations. The designer must determine the layout of the system and the depth and spacing of the drains. The slope, hydraulic gradeline, and the size of lines must be determined for both drainage and irrigation. Control structures are needed, at least in the main line, to maintain a uniform water table depth. Provisions for adjusting the weir setting (water level) must be included and should be easy to implement.
Converting from Drainage to Subirrigation. Subsurface drain spacings for subirrigation usually are 30% closer than those for drainage only. Retrofitting an existing subsurface drainage system for subirrigation may be possible in some cases by installing additional drains between existing lateral drains.
POTENTIAL PROBLEMS OF SUBIRRIGATIONSudden heavy rains during the irrigation mode may flood the root zone, especially if the weir setting (water table) is high. This problem may be solved by careful on-site management. If possible, the farmer should allow time for the soil to drain before a rain occurs. A major problem may be creating and maintaining a level water table. This is especially true in soils with low lateral hydraulic conductivity, such as clays. Problems also exist in soils that lack an adequate restrictive layer below the drain depth.
INFORMATIONFor more information, contact Larry C. Brown at the Department of Food, Agricultural and Biological Engineering at The Ohio State University. Phone: (614) 292-3826 or Internet: Brown.59@osu.edu