Home Page Project Details Research Topics Outreach and Education Major Findings
  SITE SEARCH

Research Topics > Ecology > Introduction

Click on a section to go there now: Authors & Acknowledgements | Introduction | Methods | Results

 

Effect of Reach-Level Changes in Ditch Morphology and Riparian Vegetation on Macroinvertebrate Communities in an Agricultural Landscape

Introduction

This research is a part of a large effort to improve stream ecosystem integrity and water quality within agricultural landscapes, while maintaining drainage function. Two-stage ditches that include a low depositional floodplain are being proposed as a viable alternative to the current one-stage ditch design. This feature is expected to increase channel stability and create habitat. Our objective was to determine the relative effects of riparian tree development and two-stage channel morphology on the benthic macroinvertebrate community.

Our work addresses important aspects of channel restoration within heavily farmed areas, which is highly relevant to Ohio and the Midwestern United States.

  • Crop agriculture accounts for 24% land use in the lower 48 states
  • Agriculture is listed by US EPA as the #1 cause for water quality impairment in rivers and streams
  • Channel modification due to drainage improvement efforts is a significant factor for this impairment
  • Agriculture is indispensable and soil drainage is important for productivity

Addressing Stream Impairment

  • Riparian buffers are used to mitigate nonpoint source pollution
  • Both grassed and forested buffers are shown to be effective
  • Proposed strategies for improving drainage ditch design has strong implication for riparian zone
  • Two stage ditch design

Stream Ecology

  • Strong link between riparian zone and benthic community in small streams
  • Disturbance may be a primary factor shaping stream communities
  • Aquatic community responds to land use conditions at local (reach level) scales

One-Stage Ditches

One-stage ditch
One-stage ditch
One-stage ditch at high water
One-stage ditch at high water
Newly constructed one-stage ditch
Newly constructed one-stage ditch

Charachteristics of one-stage ditches:

  • Unstable morphology leading to extreme erosion/deposition processes
  • Intensified storm flow velocity and shear stress
  • Over-widened lower energy base flow channel
  • Little flow heterogeneity
  • Typically fine bed substrate (poor quality)
  • Sparse development of habitat and flow refugia

Two-stage ditches

Two-stage ditch
Two-stage ditch
Two-stage ditch at high water
Two-stage ditch at high water
Newly constructed two-stage ditch
Newly constructed two-stage ditch

Charachteristics of two-stage ditches:

  • Successional to the one-stage ditch, and formed by erosion and deposition processes
  • May not develop in presence of riparian trees
  • Appears to be more stable form
  • May provide reduction in storm flow velocity and shear stress
  • Narrower higher energy base flow channel
  • Better riparian connection
  • Potentially improves habitat and flow refugia

Tree-Lined Ditches

Tree-lined ditch
Tree-lined ditch
Tree-lined ditch at high water
Tree-lined ditch at high water
Outside view of a tree-lined ditch
Outside view of a tree-lined ditch

Charachteristics of tree-lined ditches:

  • Often has one-stage morphology
  • Favor over-widened, lower energy base flow channel
  • Intensified storm flow velocity and shear stress
  • Provides debris, detritus, and structure that can be used as habitat, refugia and food resources
  • Reduces incident sunlight, and maintains lower temperatures

Objective and Hypotheses

Determine the relative effects of ditch morphology and riparian vegetation on benthic community assemblage at the reach level.

H1: Trees provide better habitat and food diversity than open canopied sites which enhances the benthic community.

H2: Small floodplain benches within ditches reduce the severity of disturbance events and improves habitat, which enhances the benthic community.

 

Previous: Authors & Acknowledgements | Next: Methods

 

 
 
HOME Project Details Research Topics Outreach & Education Major Findings

© 2002 - Direct questions regarding the technical operation of this site to streams_web@ag.osu.edu.